SCCG · Prediction Markets

New York AG Letitia James Files Show-Cause Order Against Kalshi After Federal Remand

north-america
New York AG Letitia James Files Show-Cause Order Against Kalshi After Federal Remand
AI-generated illustration.

New York AG Letitia James filed for a show-cause order against Kalshi after federal Judge Vernon Broderick remanded the $36 billion case to state court. The order seeks to halt operations routed through New York and impose restitution plus tripled penalties. Kalshi has signaled interest in dialogue while facing separate subpoena and council probes.

SCCG Take — The remand strengthens state enforcement against federal preemption claims, raising operational risks for prediction market platforms. Constructive CFTC-AG talks urged by Chair Selig could clarify boundaries without litigation.

New York Attorney General Letitia James filed for a show-cause order against prediction market operator Kalshi in state supreme court. The Friday filing asks Hon. Melissa Crane to require Kalshi to justify why the court should not grant a temporary restraining order, preliminary and permanent injunctions, and related remedies.

Judge Vernon Broderick of the District Court for the Southern District of New York remanded the case back to state court on Thursday. Kalshi had attempted to shift the litigation to federal court on grounds that it falls under Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) oversight. The remand follows the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals denying Kalshi an injunction pending appeal.

The order describes Kalshi as operating an unlawful gambling business without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. It cites the platform allowing users under 21 to participate and marketing to college and university campuses in the state.

What the Order Seeks

Beyond the shutdown of Kalshi operations in or routed through New York, the filing demands a full accounting of every customer account with itemized bet lists, restitution to customers who lost money, payment of damages and disgorgement of profits, and a penalty of three times the amount of its gain plus $100,000 for each unauthorized offering. These elements lead to the seismic $36 billion figure from her original action in July.

According to reporting by SBC Americas, a Kalshi spokesperson said the company wants to work with New York officials on a resolution protecting the interests of its 1.2 million users in the state. CFTC Chair Michael Selig stated his “door is always open to talk to governors and attorneys general who want to discuss legal or policy concerns. But jurisdictional disagreements should be settled through constructive dialogue, not by threatening American businesses.”

Additional Pressures on Kalshi in New York

James filed suit earlier this month to compel Kalshi to comply with August subpoenas tied to alleged deceptive marketing involving influencer payments. The New York City Council launched an investigation in August into Kalshi and other prediction markets operators over predatory marketing practices.

SCCG Media · Daily briefing

Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.

Subscribe →

Related

SponsoredThe Service Companies — SCCG partnerRegulatory Pressure Intensifies on Prediction Markets with New York Filing and Multi-State OppositionCFTC Charges Two Indiana Executives and Eleven Entities with Operating $550 Million Forex Ponzi Scheme
Curated by SCCG · Powered by SCCG Technology