SCCG · Prediction Markets

Regulatory Pressure Intensifies on Prediction Markets with New York Filing and Multi-State Opposition

north-america
Regulatory Pressure Intensifies on Prediction Markets with New York Filing and Multi-State Opposition
AI-generated illustration.

NY AG Letitia James refiled a TRO to block Kalshi from offering unlicensed event contracts, with added age-21 and marketing limits. A 43-state coalition opposes the CFTC's October 9 swaps rule, citing lack of authority. The Fourth Circuit's 2-1 pro-Maryland ruling deepens a circuit split on state enforcement power.

SCCG Take — States are defending their gambling authority against federal reclassification risks that could sidestep licensing and protections. Operators face fragmented rules until courts resolve the jurisdictional divide.

According to reporting by CDC Gaming, prediction markets are confronting coordinated legal and regulatory challenges from state officials and courts.

Attorney General Letitia James refiled a proposed motion for a temporary restraining order in Manhattan Supreme Court on Friday. The filing seeks to immediately prohibit Kalshi from offering sports, culture, election, and other contracts within or from New York or to persons in New York without being licensed by the New York State Gaming Commission. The order applies regardless of customers' physical location in the state.

New York Actions Target Operations and Marketing

Daniel Wallach, a gaming attorney, warned in a post on X that the TRO could carry major implications for New York-based prediction market exchanges. Both Kalshi and Polymarket maintain headquarters in the state. Wallach noted the provision barring anyone under 21 from purchasing contracts aligns with New York's minimum age for legal sports betting.

The filing also addresses advertising, marketing, and soliciting of covered event contracts. It specifically references college campuses and university-owned newspapers, radio, and telecast. New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani criticized the expansion of betting at the New York Times DealBook Summit. "It does degrade so much of life to make everything the subject of a bet," the mayor said, according to The Hill.

State Coalition and Court Rulings Test Federal Boundaries

A bipartisan coalition of 42 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia, co-led by Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, submitted comments urging the CFTC to withdraw its proposed rule released on October 9. The proposal would expand the definition of swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act to cover contracts tied to sports, politics, culture, and weather. "A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so," the letter states.

The coalition argues the rule would undermine states' authority, bypass licensing and age restrictions, and weaken consumer protections including those against problem gambling. It further challenges the agency's quorum with only one commissioner serving. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig maintains these products fall within the agency's exclusive jurisdiction.

In a separate matter, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 in Maryland's favor. The decision denies Kalshi's appeal of state regulators' enforcement rights against unlicensed sports-event contracts. Kalshi called the splintered opinions contradictory and lacking a unified legal argument, increasing prospects for Supreme Court review. Co-founder Tarek Mansour instead pointed to the Third Circuit's favorable ruling for Kalshi in New Jersey, adding that this is a big win for the industry and millions of users. James Baker, acting director of the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Agency, said the ruling affirmed the state's ability to regulate what is clearly sports wagering.

Where the Risk Lies

The circuit split and state resistance create compliance uncertainty for platforms. Operators and investors should anticipate continued state-level enforcement and potential Supreme Court intervention to delineate boundaries between federal derivatives oversight and traditional gambling regulation.

SCCG Media · Daily briefing

Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.

Subscribe →

Related

SponsoredThe Service Companies — SCCG partnerCFTC Charges Two Indiana Executives and Eleven Entities with Operating $550 Million Forex Ponzi SchemePolymarket CEO Shayne Coplan Says Speculation Around Donald Trump Jr. Role Is Heavily Overblown
Curated by SCCG · Powered by SCCG Technology