
''
SCCG Take — The splintered opinions favor state regulators now but highlight the need for Supreme Court clarity on federal exclusivity. Operators must weigh state licensing risks against the potential for nationwide resolution.
The unsettled legal status of sports prediction markets grew more complex this week after a divided three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit ruled against Kalshi. The court held that the company's sports event contracts are subject to state gambling laws, including Maryland's requirement for a sports wagering license. The decision featured two concurrences and a dissent, with the judges offering sharply different reasons for the outcome.
4th Circuit Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker both sided with Maryland gaming regulator John Martin, rejecting Kalshi's claim of exemption from state gambling rules. Gregory declined to decide whether the contracts qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. He instead stressed states' longstanding authority over gambling and found that Congress had not clearly displaced that power for sports prediction contracts. Those contracts, he noted, bear a strong resemblance to sports bets.
Thacker took a different route to the same result. She concluded the contracts are not swaps because they pay out based on the result of an event rather than whether or to what extent an event takes place. "What is happening here is sports betting," Thacker asserted. "In both sporting event-based contracts and traditional sports bets, two parties enter an agreement in which the party that correctly predicts the outcome of a sporting event gets paid. That is gambling, plain and simple."
Judge DeAndrea G. Benjamin dissented. She agreed with Kalshi that the contracts are swaps dependent on the occurrence of an event with financial consequences, granting the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction. Benjamin rejected the occurrence-outcome distinction, writing that the terms "are not mutually exclusive."
The ruling joins decisions from the 9th and 6th Circuits against Kalshi, while the 3rd Circuit previously agreed with the company. As reported by Sportico, the conflicting rationales increase the odds of U.S. Supreme Court review.
Kalshi stated that "judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong. This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets."
Until the high court acts on pending petitions, prediction market operators face inconsistent enforcement across jurisdictions. The absence of uniform federal preemption leaves room for states to impose licensing and operational requirements that directly affect market access and compliance costs.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →