
The ECJ deemed inadmissible an Austrian referral seeking clarity on Malta’s 2023 Bill 55 and its alignment with EU law. The underlying case concerned a litigation funder’s negligence claim against a legal adviser, which the court said could be resolved without addressing the bill’s compatibility. Other pending ECJ matters may still produce a ruling.
SCCG Take — The sidestep sustains ambiguity for Maltese licensees and EU enforcement actions. Operators and funders must monitor parallel cases for the definitive guidance this referral failed to deliver.
The European Court of Justice has declared inadmissible an Austrian court's request for a preliminary ruling on whether Malta’s Bill 55 is compatible with EU law. The decision leaves the legislation's status under EU law unaddressed.
Bill 55, introduced in 2023, prohibits legal actions against Maltese-licensed gambling operators and blocks recognition or enforcement in Malta of foreign judgments tied to such actions, including grey market activity. The bill has faced criticism as contrary to EU law. A separate ECJ ruling in April confirmed member states may pursue operators that fail to follow their gambling regulations.
The matter arose from litigation pursued by Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian funder that obtained rulings for refunds of player losses from MGA-licensed operators active in Austria without a local licence. Spielerschutz Sigma secured a legal opinion that Bill 55 was incompatible with EU law and therefore inapplicable to enforcement proceedings in Malta.
A Maltese court declined to apply an Austrian judgment, prompting Spielerschutz Sigma to sue its legal adviser for compensation over fees and losses incurred in reliance on that opinion. The Austrian court referred questions to the ECJ.
The ECJ determined an interpretation of EU law was not necessary to resolve the dispute, which turned on whether the adviser had acted negligently under Austrian law by providing a reasonably defensible opinion based on the framework then available. “In those circumstances, the Court notes that the lawfulness and proper performance of the reciprocal obligations of the parties to the legal consultation at issue are independent of the question of the compatibility of the relevant Maltese legislation with EU law,” the ECJ said.
ECJ Press Officer Jacques René Zammit confirmed to iGaming Business that the judgment did not reach the compatibility of Bill 55 with EU law. “In this case, it did not go into that, no,” Zammit said. He added that other cases currently before the ECJ could result in a ruling on the issue.
The outcome adds uncertainty for parties relying on the legislation's effect in cross-border gambling matters.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →