
CFTC proposal on sports event contracts as swaps drew 140 comments by Nov. 18, far below prior rounds of 3,500 and 1,400. Tribes led opposition citing sovereignty and IGRA conflicts while prediction firms and three Kalshi-partnered tribes supported oversight for clarity. Market volume estimates also drew scrutiny.
SCCG Take — Sparse input and tribal split point to CFTC finalization favoring prediction markets, but set up litigation risks for operators over authority and IGRA preemption.
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission received 140 public comments on its proposal to include sports event contracts in the definition of swaps, with most submissions arriving in the final two days before the November 18 deadline. As reported by Gambling Insider, tribal organizations drove opposition on grounds that the move threatens tribal sovereignty and existing gambling regulations, while prediction market operators and financial firms backed federal oversight.
Opposition also came from a coalition of 43 states and Washington, D.C., the American Gaming Association, Utah Gov. Spencer Cox and Attorney General Derek Brown, and Rep. Dina Titus of Nevada. Three of the four tribes that partnered with Kalshi supported the proposal instead. The National Congress of American Indians, representing approximately 300 tribal nations, stated: “Simply labeling these wagers as swaps does not change their underlying nature as gambling.” The Oklahoma Indian Gaming Association warned that the approach “provides an end-run around tribal sovereignty and interferes with Tribal interests.” The Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria added that such contracts “threaten the entire economic foundation of tribal governments.”
Cox and Brown highlighted risks of gambling addiction, household financial harm, and erosion of state regulatory power. The American Gaming Association questioned whether the CFTC appreciates the market scale, contrasting the agency’s $1.5 billion monthly trading estimate with over $39 billion in the first week of November alone. Several comments cited the Ninth Circuit ruling that sports event contracts on tribal lands could violate the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act even if deemed swaps. Boyd Gaming warned that an overly broad definition might eventually reach traditional casino games.
Kalshi, Polymarket US, Coinbase, Gemini, Novig, Underdog, Andreessen Horowitz, and the Coalition for Prediction Markets endorsed the change. Coinbase stated: “The Proposal would confirm what the Commodity Exchange Act (‘CEA’) already makes clear.” Underdog disclosed it has self-certified more than 500 sports event contracts as swaps. The Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town, Alturas Indian Rancheria, and Greenville Rancheria argued that federally regulated contracts and tribal gaming can coexist without undermining the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. One cited a $60,000 Kalshi hedge by a Los Angeles hospitality group on the Dodgers.
This comment period drew far fewer responses than prior steps, which exceeded 3,500 and 1,400 comments respectively and featured broader input from leagues, lawmakers, and academics. The narrower focus on swap status explains the concentration among directly affected tribal and prediction market voices. The CFTC is expected to finalize the rule given its defense of jurisdiction, delivering certainty to prediction platforms while exposing operators to sustained legal and regulatory pushback from tribes and states.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →