
Utah AG Derek Brown detailed court wins over Kalshi, new criminal charges against its CEO and COO, and operator exits from the state. Florida AG James Uthmeier flagged DraftKings' 21 Rivals as casino gambling and promised further contact. The moves show states defending their authority against federal preemption claims.
SCCG Take — Operators must treat state gambling bans as binding regardless of federal derivatives arguments or product labeling to avoid criminal exposure and market exits.
Attorneys general in Utah and Florida used social media on Wednesday to warn prediction market operators and sports betting companies that their activities violate state law.
Utah Attorney General Derek Brown stated that gambling is illegal in the state whether one places the bet, runs the game, or promotes it. Brown noted that Utah has prohibited gambling since it became a state in 1896, covering casinos, lotteries, and online gambling. He referenced apps attempting to operate as prediction markets while still offering gambling.
Kalshi sued Utah officials, arguing that the federal Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC oversight preempt state gambling laws. U.S. District Judge Robert Shelby ruled in favor of Utah, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit declined to block the state's laws. Last month, the CFTC filed its own federal lawsuit against the state to assert sole jurisdiction over derivatives and event contracts.
Brown said the state won in court and responded with criminal charges against Kalshi and its co-founders, CEO Tarek Mansour and COO Luana Lopes Lara. The charges include 13 felony counts such as online-gambling promotion plus a misdemeanor gambling charge. Mansour and Lopes Lara must appear in Utah’s Third District Court in Salt Lake City on December 4. Kalshi dismissed the charges against the co-founders as political overreach.
In response, DraftKings blocked sports, novelty, and political event contracts for Utah users while keeping financial contracts available. Fanatics stopped all trading for state residents. FanDuel shut down its prediction market operations entirely. Robinhood restricted new event-contract positions on sports, culture, elections, and politics. Brown described these steps as "a victory and this is exactly what we were hoping to see."
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier targeted DraftKings over its new peer-to-peer platform called 21 Rivals. Uthmeier said if it "looks like a casino, takes real money like a casino, and pays out like a casino, it is a casino." He added that "DraftKings will be hearing from us soon."
DraftKings describes 21 Rivals as a five-round card game in which customers compete head-to-head on a six-minute clock against a simulated dealer, deciding whether to hit, stand, double, or split. Chips have no cash value and cannot be cashed out; the higher chip balance wins a pre-selected prize. The game is slated to launch in Florida plus Texas, New York, Virginia, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, North Carolina, and Alabama, according to reporting by CDC Gaming.
These enforcement messages underscore states' insistence on applying long-standing gambling prohibitions to new product categories.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →