SCCG · Partners Hub

Lord Foster Challenges UK Gambling Commission Stance on Pokémon Cards

europe
Lord Foster Challenges UK Gambling Commission Stance on Pokémon Cards
AI-generated illustration.

Lord Foster argues Pokémon cards' resale value meets the "money's worth" test under the Gambling Act 2005, urging scrutiny of their trade and youth appeal. The Commission maintains secondary markets do not turn initial sales into gambling and cites parliamentary intent. The letters surface amid a fresh statutory review launched in November 2026.

SCCG Take — Boundary disputes like this highlight enforcement limits within current definitions. The ongoing Gambling Act review must address collectibles to prevent regulatory gaps or unintended criminalisation.

Lord Foster has challenged the Gambling Commission’s view that buying Pokémon cards falls outside gambling legislation. In a letter dated 21 July 2026, the chair of Peers for Gambling Reform argued that the established resale market raises questions about whether the cards count as “money’s worth” under the Gambling Act 2005. Some cards possess clear financial value and trade through mainstream commercial channels, he said.

Foster contrasted the physical cards with digital loot box items. He noted their appeal to younger audiences and called the issue a matter of wider public interest. A recent auction sale of a Pokémon collection for £1.56 million illustrated the cash trading that occurs, according to reporting by iGaming Business.

Argument for Regulatory Reconsideration

Foster said it was “not immediately apparent” why cards with “objectively ascertainable financial value” that “can readily be exchanged for cash” should be excluded from the gambling definition. Many people collect for enjoyment, yet the Commission should examine how the cards are bought, sold and valued. He linked them to broader “gambling-like” products that can lead to real gambling and referenced a 2020 House of Lords report that recommended changing the definition.

Commission Response and Statutory Limits

Sarah Gardner, the Commission’s acting chief executive, replied on 11 August that subsequent trading on a secondary market does not mean the original sale constitutes gambling. Parliament had not intended the Act to cover trading cards or football stickers simply because purchase involves an element of chance, Gardner wrote. The regulator is not currently undertaking activity on collectable cards or stickers.

Gardner added that the Commission must protect children and vulnerable people from gambling-related harm but must stay within definitions set by Parliament. Stringent requirements that prevent young people from collecting or risk criminalising them were not the outcome Parliament intended. The newly established Gambling Policy Commission has since launched a review of the Gambling Act 2005 at the start of November.

SCCG Media · Daily briefing

Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.

Subscribe →

Related

SponsoredBTA Sports — SCCG partnerPennsylvania Gaming Control Board Fines Live! Casino Philadelphia Operator $26,500 for Incorrect Blackjack Payout Layout…Amelco Argues Sportsbooks Can Manage Sharp Bettors Without Blanket Account Limits
Curated by SCCG · Powered by SCCG Technology