SCCG · Prediction Markets

Fourth Circuit Rules 2-1 Against Kalshi in Maryland Sports Wagering Appeal

north-america
Fourth Circuit Rules 2-1 Against Kalshi in Maryland Sports Wagering Appeal
AI-generated illustration.

A divided Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals sided with Maryland on Tuesday denying Kalshi’s appeal in a 2-1 ruling. Differing majority opinions by Judge Roger Gregory and Judge Stephanie Thacker contrasted with a dissent by Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin favoring CFTC exclusivity. This follows Kalshi's 2-1 Third Circuit win over New Jersey in April.

SCCG Take — Splintered rationales across circuits confirm no settled preemption rule, forcing operators to litigate state-by-state until en banc or legislative clarity emerges.

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals sided with Maryland on Tuesday in a 2-1 decision denying Kalshi's appeal. The case turns on whether sports event contracts qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). This marks the third loss for Kalshi in four circuit court appeals.

Judge Roger Gregory, an appointee of President Bill Clinton and George W. Bush, concurred that gambling regulation remains a traditional state police power. "Because the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, I would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland’s concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so," Gregory wrote. He found no preemption because complying with both the CEA and Maryland law is not impossible.

Judge Stephanie Thacker reached the same result by a different route. She stressed that Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010 after the 2008 financial crisis to promote financial stability and bring risky products under oversight. "This stated purpose of Dodd-Frank has nothing to do with sports betting," Thacker concluded. Therefore sporting event contracts are not swaps.

Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented. She noted the rise in prediction markets but said Congress assigned exclusive jurisdiction over swaps to the CFTC. "Because Kalshi’s sports-related contracts qualify as ‘swaps,’ I would conclude that Maryland’s laws are field preempted."

A Kalshi spokesperson called the outcome splintered. "Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong. This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets."

Contrasting Third Circuit Outcome

In April the Third Circuit Court of Appeals issued its own 2-1 ruling in Kalshi’s favor against New Jersey regulators. That decision blocked the state from banning sports event contracts and placed them under CFTC oversight.

Tarek Mansour, Kalshi co-founder and CEO, called it “a big win for the industry” without referencing the split. He posted verbatim: "The Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi’s favor. People use prediction markets because they’re more fair, transparent, and reward being right. Free markets work. We should keep them that way. This is a big win for the industry and millions of users."

Co-founder Luana Lopes Lara tweeted: "I might go for a ride at the jersey shore today."

According to reporting by SBC Americas, Kalshi could ask for an en banc rehearing in the Fourth Circuit as it has done after prior losses at that level. The paired 2-1 outcomes expose divergent judicial views on the same core question of federal preemption versus state authority over these contracts.

SCCG Media · Daily briefing

Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.

Subscribe →

Related

SponsoredFrame Payments — SCCG partnerGibraltar Selects Stephen Hodgson to Lead Gambling Regulation from Early 2027Utah Attorney General Sues Stake.us for Unauthorized Gambling Since 2022 and Files Criminal Charges Against Kalshi
Curated by SCCG · Powered by SCCG Technology