
The Democratic congressional sweep may block replacements for Supreme Court Justices Alito and Thomas, clouding a potential 2027 ruling on sports event contracts. Polymarket odds for granting cert in 2026 have dropped to 21% after the Ninth Circuit denied Kalshi's rehearing petition. Prediction market volume hit $185B in Q3.
SCCG Take — Prediction market operators and CFTC-regulated platforms face prolonged jurisdictional uncertainty if Senate resistance delays any shift in Court composition.
The Democratic "Blue Sweep" of both chambers of Congress in the 2026 midterms has immediate implications for the composition of the U.S. Supreme Court. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis warned in a post on X that received more than 3.1 million hits that the odds of "confirming a worthy successor" to Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas during the remainder of President Trump's presidency are virtually "zero." This dynamic arrives as a case on the legality of sports event contracts classified as swaps could reach the high court as early as next year.
According to iGaming Business reporting, Clarence Thomas was appointed by George H.W. Bush approximately a year before PASPA became effective in 1992 and remains the longest serving justice. Samuel Alito was appointed in October 2005 by George W. Bush to replace Sandra Day O'Connor. The source recalls the 2016 death of Chief Justice Antonin Scalia and the 293-day delay of Merrick Garland's nomination, which cleared the path for Neil Gorsuch.
The article details how Senate Democrats, fresh from the midterm victories, may resist any effort to replace the two justices before the next presidential election. One scenario involves White House pressure on Alito and Thomas to retire, followed by nominations aligned with the conservative bloc. Yet Democratic control raises the prospect of gridlock and potential 4-4 splits on major cases, including federal preemption questions around sports event contracts.
Prediction markets experienced notional volume surpassing $185 billion over the third quarter. Midterm-related activity alone reached at least $1.4 billion, exceeding non-presidential election volumes from 2024. Michael Selig, nominated by Trump to chair the CFTC, has maintained that the agency holds exclusive jurisdiction over sports derivatives despite criticism from state and tribal gaming regulators and questions involving Trump family business ties to platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit denied Kalshi's petition for rehearing, affording the company 90 days to seek Supreme Court review. On Polymarket, the odds of the court granting certiorari by the end of 2026 stand at 21%. Those odds had peaked at 82% in February and hit a low of 14% around Halloween. Former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie indicated satisfaction with the current court's composition on states' rights issues.
Where the Risk Lies
A stalled confirmation process could leave the existing bench intact but introduce timing uncertainty for the pending case. Operators in the prediction market space now confront the possibility that divergent lower court rulings on event contracts remain unresolved into 2027 or beyond, prolonging regulatory ambiguity around CFTC authority versus state oversight.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →