
Sportsbook handle across 15 states was $11.11 billion in September, down 0.3% YoY, while Kalshi hit $60.28 billion notional volume and four exchanges reached $75.5 billion. Revenue and hold rates varied widely by state. The data shows football demand supported both sectors without clear evidence of material cannibalization.
SCCG Take — Operators should track customer migration signals in Q3 earnings and October handle. Parallel growth is sustainable short-term, but sustained flatness amid prediction market expansion will pressure traditional pricing and hold.
Sportsbook handle across 15 states reached $11.11 billion in September, down an estimated 0.3% year over year. Seven states posted gains, seven saw declines, and Iowa held roughly even. The figures come as prediction markets shattered volume records with the return of NFL and college football, according to reporting by Gambling Insider.
The performance marks a stabilization after an August slowdown. The American Gaming Association had flagged a 0.7% nationwide decline in August to $10.89 billion, attributing part of the weakness to prediction market competition and a delayed college football schedule. Summer strength from the 2026 FIFA World Cup had lifted online handle 24% in June and 30% in July before that pullback.
Revenue diverged sharply from handle in several states. New York posted $159.4 million in gross gaming revenue, down 17.7% despite a 5% handle increase. New Jersey revenue fell 14.3% to $77 million on a 3.6% handle drop. Maryland and North Carolina showed similar revenue weakness.
Other states moved in the opposite direction. Ohio revenue rose 12.8% to $87.7 million even as handle slipped 2.2%. Pennsylvania taxable revenue jumped 50.5% to $44.7 million despite a 6.1% handle decline. These gaps trace to hold rates: New York's hold fell from 8.47% to 6.64%, and Maryland's dropped from 11.2% to 9.0%. Bettor-friendly outcomes compressed margins independent of volume.
According to TickerTracker, Kalshi generated $60.28 billion in September notional volume, up 56.4% from August. Four major exchanges totaled $75.5 billion. Q3 notional volume across Kalshi, Polymarket, Polymarket US, and Novig hit $179.6 billion, an 84.3% quarterly increase. Football weekends drove peaks, with Kalshi alone clearing $5.83 billion on one mid-September Sunday.
Notional volume counts contracts at $1 settlement value, not dollars paid. Prediction Frontier calculated actual dollars paid at $14.7 billion for Kalshi's September notional figure and $56.1 billion for the full Q3 total. The measures are not equivalent to sportsbook handle, and platform-wide prediction data cannot be mapped directly onto the 15-state sample.
The September results leave the competitive overlap between the two markets unresolved. Football clearly lifted demand for both, yet the flat sportsbook handle does not prove prediction platforms are pulling customers away. October figures and third-quarter earnings from major operators will supply the next data points on whether this balance holds.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →