
UKGC research found 45% of illegal site users scored 8+ on the PGSI versus 6% on licensed sites, based on 157.2 million transactions. Illegal activity overlaps heavily with licensed play, as 91% of such users also bet legally and transaction volumes stayed stable. The data does not prove causation or measure overall illegal market size due to detection gaps.
SCCG Take — The embedded overlap highlights that enforcement cannot assume substitution. Regulators must improve non-banking detection methods to address coexistence with licensed operators.
The UK Gambling Commission has found that individuals using illegal gambling websites in Britain are more than seven times as likely to show signs of problem gambling than those on licensed sites.
45% of players on illegal websites scored eight or higher on the Problem Gambling Severity Index. That compares with 6% of gamblers using licensed websites. A score of eight or above indicates problem gambling behavior. The Commission added that its findings do not establish whether illegal sites cause greater gambling harm.
The research examined banking transactions between July 2018 and July 2026. It also found that 17% of illegal gambling users had PGSI scores between three and seven, compared with 9% of licensed customers.
The study revealed that illegal gambling is embedded within existing behavior rather than replacing licensed play. Among individuals with repeated transactions involving illegal operators, 91% also gambled with licensed companies.
The UKGC said it found little evidence that customers stopped using regulated websites after beginning to gamble illegally. Of the 122 individuals with at least two detected illegal gambling transactions, the average number of monthly licensed gambling transactions was 24.8 in the preceding month compared with 23.7 in the following month.
“Illegal gambling is embedded within existing gambling behavior rather than triggering a sustained shift away from the licensed market,” the report concluded.
The UKGC analyzed 157.2 million banking transactions from approximately 38,000 individuals using data collected by YouGov. It identified 3,426 transactions believed to involve illegal gambling operators, made by 179 individuals.
Identifying illegal payments proved difficult. An initial attempt to match known illegal operator names against banking descriptions failed, as illegal operators rarely include their business names in payment information. The method also missed cryptocurrency transactions. As a result, the findings could not establish the size of Britain’s illegal gambling market, according to Casino.org News.
Others have estimated the black market scale, with the Betting and Gaming Council warning that UK black market Premier League betting could hit £1 billion ($1.36 billion) by the 2027/28 season. The distinction on causation remains central to how regulators interpret the data for ongoing oversight.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →