SCCG · Responsible Gaming

UK Gambling Commission Study Ties Illegal Sites to 45% Problem Gambling Rate

europe
UK Gambling Commission Study Ties Illegal Sites to 45% Problem Gambling Rate
AI-generated illustration.

The Gambling Commission study shows 45% of illegal-site users have PGSI scores of 8+, versus 6% for legal operators, with 91% overlap between the two. Based on 179 transactions, it also notes persistent use of unlicensed platforms. The findings link black-market activity more strongly to harm.

SCCG Take — 'Regulated operators face a dual imperative: comply with rising tax and compliance burdens while preventing at-risk customers from migrating to illegal sites that show far higher harm rates.'

The UK Gambling Commission study has found a clear link between illegal online gambling and higher rates of harm. 45% of those transacting with illegal operators recorded a Problem Gambling Severity Index (PGSI) score of eight or more. This compares with 6% of customers using legal companies.

A further 16% of illegal-site users scored three-to-seven on the PGSI, against 8% for regulated operators. The Commission identified substantial overlap: 91% of people who used illegal firms also gambled with the licensed sector. The sample covered 179 individuals’ transactions, with PGSI scores available for 146. Participants were mostly male and had an average age of 44.

Consistency of Black Market Engagement

Once customers engaged with unlicensed sites they tended to persist. Average transactions with illegal platforms reached 4.9 in the first month, then fell to 1.8 after two months, 1.4 after three, rose to 1.9 after four, and settled at 1.2 and 1.5 in months five and six respectively.

Dan Waugh, Partner at Regulus Partners, said the pattern is consistent with wider research literature and reinforces concerns about growth in unlicensed gambling. An industry source told SBC News that campaigners and others have been closing their eyes to the threat illegal sites pose. “You can’t hope a problem away.” A spokesperson for Flutter UKI, operator of Paddy Power, Betfair and Sky Bet, said the figures highlight why government and the regulator must tackle the illegal and unlicensed market.

Why the Overlap Demands Attention

The overlap means many customers showing problem-gambling indicators remain active in the regulated market at the same time. The regulated sector therefore cannot treat the black-market problem as entirely separate. With Machine Games Duty now rising to 25% and new financial vulnerability checks in force, the data supplies both vindication for the licensed industry’s arguments and a direct prompt to tighten harm-prevention controls so fewer at-risk customers seek unlicensed alternatives. Operators and regulators will need to address this dual exposure rather than hope the illegal market simply disappears.

SCCG Media · Daily briefing

Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.

Subscribe →

Related

SponsoredFrame Payments — SCCG partnerKindbridge Research Institute Targets Gambling Disorders Among Veterans With New Study and Stigma Stand Down ProgramBaccarat Variants Explained: Punto Banco, Chemin de Fer, and Baccarat Banque
Curated by SCCG · Powered by SCCG Technology