
New York sports betting handle exceeded $2.4 billion in September, up 5% year-over-year, while fiscal-year volume rose 6.9% to $12.6 billion. Revenue fell 5.8% to $1.1 billion on a lower hold. The AGA estimates $1.6 billion in lost state tax revenue from prediction markets since late 2025.
SCCG Take — New York growth indicates prediction markets have not materially eroded leading state volumes, yet the reduced hold requires operators to adjust pricing and risk models to protect margins.
New York sports betting handle grew in September despite regulated industry arguments that prediction markets divert spending from state-licensed operators. The New York State Gaming Commission reported more than $2.4 billion in wagers for the month. That total delivered a 5% increase from September 2025, adding nearly $114 million.
Cumulative volume through September stands 3.7% above the prior year with roughly $697 million in additional bets. The state's 2026/2027 fiscal year shows firmer growth. The first six months produced nearly $12.6 billion in handle, a 6.9% rise over the same period in 2025.
Higher betting volume has not lifted revenue. Bettor performance improved and the hold eased from 10% to 8.8%, driving a 5.8% revenue decline to $1.1 billion for the six-month span.
New York remains the largest sports betting jurisdiction among the 39 states with legal markets. Licensed platforms include Bally Bet, BetMGM, BetRivers, Caesars Sportsbook, DraftKings, theScore, Fanatics, FanDuel, and Resorts World Bet. Illinois posted $9.3 billion in online handle through August, a 5.7% gain from $8.8 billion the year before. New Jersey recorded a 4.1% drop through September, with handle falling from $8.6 billion to $8.3 billion.
The regulated sector continues to assert that prediction markets encroach on state sportsbooks and reduce tax receipts. The American Gaming Association placed projected lost state gaming tax revenue near $1.6 billion since these platforms started offering back-door sports betting in late 2025. The AGA said, "Prediction market platforms are offering illegal sports betting nationwide outside the state and tribal regulatory frameworks that protect consumers. They override voter decisions, bypass key consumer protections, ignore state and tribal laws, and avoid licensing and taxes." It added, "Prediction markets contribute nothing."
The New York figures supply a counterpoint to claims of substantial volume diversion even as prediction markets expand. Sustained handle growth paired with compressed hold and lower revenue reveals the immediate operational tension for sportsbooks. Operators will track whether bettor win rates stabilize and whether regulatory responses to prediction market activity alter the balance between licensed and unregulated trading in the months ahead.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →