
Underdog sued Tennessee officials Tuesday over an order to stop offering sports event contracts. The complaint argues that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission exclusive authority over its federally regulated markets, preventing Tennessee from applying state gambling laws. The lawsuit comes less than three weeks after the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Kalshi’s attempt.
SCCG Take — This suit sharpens the federal-state jurisdictional clash over prediction markets. Operators need clear Supreme Court guidance to manage license risks across conflicting rulings.
Underdog sued Tennessee officials after the state issued a cease-and-desist order classifying the company’s sports event contracts as wagers under the Tennessee Sports Gaming Act. The complaint argues that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission exclusive jurisdiction, preempting state gambling laws. It seeks a declaratory judgment and permanent injunction against enforcement.
The suit arrives less than three weeks after the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Kalshi’s bid for similar protection in Tennessee and Ohio. Underdog acknowledges that precedent but states it must preserve its appellate rights as competing interpretations advance toward the U.S. Supreme Court. As reported by SBC Americas, the filing also references a recent CFTC proposed rule defining sports event contracts as swaps.
The Tennessee Sports Wagering Council sent Underdog a cease-and-desist letter citing the Sixth Circuit decision. The letter warned of fines ranging from $10,000 to $25,000 per offense, plus civil penalties and possible law enforcement referral. It explicitly stated that continued offering of the contracts would place Underdog’s fantasy sports operator license at risk of revocation.
Underdog’s complaint counters that its fantasy sports operations run through a separate affiliate and remain distinct from the exchange and brokerage activities. It argues the state cannot use fantasy licensing authority to regulate activity exclusively under federal oversight.
Underdog has now sued seven states with parallel claims: Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Mexico, Ohio, Washington and Wisconsin. The CFTC has filed related suits challenging state actions in Arizona, Illinois, Kentucky, Minnesota and others. The Third Circuit upheld a preliminary injunction for Kalshi in New Jersey, finding preemption, while the Ninth Circuit recognized federal preemption in Nevada but still denied an injunction.
The NFL, attorneys general from 39 states and the District of Columbia, Robinhood and Crypto.com have all urged Supreme Court review. A ruling is likely as the circuit split deepens on whether these contracts qualify as CFTC-regulated swaps immune from state wagering laws.
Reporting: SBC Americas
Generated by SCCG’s automated editorial system from published source reporting. SCCG Management holds editorial responsibility.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →