
The NFL filed an amicus brief backing New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition on whether CFTC-regulated prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket are legal. It cites integrity risks from injury bets, weather wagers, an 18 betting age, and unauthorized logo use. Operators and the CFTC defend federal oversight as active and comprehensive.
SCCG Take — A ruling favoring state authority would let the NFL press for tighter CFTC measures before 2027, reducing uncertainty but raising compliance costs for prediction platforms.
The NFL has filed an amicus brief supporting New Jersey’s petition for U.S. Supreme Court review of whether federally regulated prediction markets such as those from Kalshi and Polymarket are legal. The league argues that clarity is essential to protect professional football amid ongoing state litigation and a circuit split over sports wagering oversight.
Sportico reported that the NFL maintains the 6th and 9th circuits correctly held that federal rules likely do not preempt state laws. The brief criticizes the CFTC’s approach as too permissive and notes the agency has yet to finalize prediction-market-specific rules despite being in the process of doing so.
The NFL has expressed frustration for more than a year with bets tied to player injuries and weather delays, as well as the platforms’ minimum betting age of 18 versus the 21 standard used by most state sportsbooks. Kalshi and Polymarket have also used NFL logos and marks without permission from the league or the NFLPA.
The brief states that if the court sides with the 3rd Circuit and deems the CFTC the exclusive regulator, the NFL and others could push the commission, the designated contract markets, and Congress for stronger integrity and consumer protections before the 2027 NFL season. This reflects the league’s view that the current landscape undermines game integrity.
Kalshi, Polymarket, and the CFTC contested the NFL’s position. Kalshi stated that the CFTC is actively policing sports-related markets listed on nearly every U.S. commodities exchange and that its rulemaking addresses the cited concerns within a federal enforcement system that protects trillions of dollars in transactions. Polymarket said it shares the NFL’s commitment to preserving the integrity of the game through advanced surveillance tools and collaboration with the CFTC, SEC, and leagues for a harmonized federal framework superior to state-by-state rules.
CFTC public affairs director Brooke Nethercott wrote that the agency has engaged with the NFL since day one on rulemaking and priorities. She called it unfortunate that the NFL declined a memorandum of understanding, unlike MLB earlier this year. The counterarguments underscore limits in the NFL’s framing while highlighting existing federal tools.
The dispute reveals genuine friction over preemption and consumer safeguards that only Supreme Court review or accelerated rulemaking can resolve ahead of future seasons.
Reporting: Sportico
Generated by SCCG’s automated editorial system from published source reporting. SCCG Management holds editorial responsibility.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →