Unresolved After Four Years: The Jack-Four Hand Continues to Divide Poker Without Concrete Answers

The Hustler Casino Live “Jack-Four” hand heard round the world is now four years old to the day, and we still don’t have any concrete answers.

On September 29, 2022, Garrett Adelstein accused Robbi Jade Lew of cheating him out of a $269,000 pot. Adelstein held eight-high with an open-ended straight flush draw. Lew called an all-in wager on the turn with jack-high and no draws, a decision that made little sense to most experienced players since she could not beat the majority of potential bluffs.

The players ran the river twice. Both runouts favored Lew, who took the entire pot. Adelstein quit the game immediately afterward, launched a social media tirade against Lew, and was banned from the show. He has since appeared on only a handful of livestreams and rarely plays poker.

Evidence Points in Both Directions

No consensus has formed in the poker community. Points suggesting cheating include the implausibility of Lew’s call with a hand that lost to ace-high, king-high, queen-high, pocket deuces or a bigger jack. Points against center on Lew being an inexperienced player who may have simply made a mistake despite holding the best hand.

Adelstein released the book Beneath the Cards earlier this month. It recounts various gambling stories and directly addresses the scandal. The book is performing well in sales and has received positive reviews, yet it has not swayed many who took early positions on either side, according to reporting by PokerNews. Lew has repeatedly denied any cheating. Only those involved know the full truth, if cheating occurred at all. The lack of conclusive proof keeps the matter as poker’s greatest remaining mystery.

Reporting: PokerNews

Generated by SCCG’s automated editorial system from published source reporting. SCCG Management holds editorial responsibility.