
Download the Full Report (Free PDF)
Since April, one casino company has left the stock market, a second has agreed to leave, a third came close, and a fourth has put nine casinos up for sale. Our November research report asks why the people who know these businesses best are taking them off the board.
On 30 April, Golden Entertainment returned to private, family ownership. On 22 September, Caesars shareholders approved Tilman Fertitta's $17.6 billion takeover. The next day, Barry Diller's People Inc. withdrew its offer to take MGM Resorts private. And Churchill Downs is selling nine regional casinos, saying its share price has not reflected "the quality, durability, and cash-generating characteristics" of its properties.
Four stories, one message. The stock market has stopped paying full price for American casinos, and the people closest to them have noticed.
Fertitta Entertainment agreed to pay $31 a share for Caesars, 49 percent more than the stock was worth before talk of a deal began. People Inc. offered $48.30 a share for the MGM shares it didn't own. Churchill Downs, after its shares fell about 7 percent on the sale news, approved a $750 million buyback of its own stock. Nobody pays that kind of premium, or buys back their own shares, if they think the market has the price right.
Every casino produces cash. The question is who gets paid out of it, and in what order. In the third quarter, Caesars' casinos produced $865 million of adjusted EBITDA, a common measure of the cash a business earns before interest and taxes. Its interest bill was $570 million, and it also pays rent to its landlords, VICI and GLPI. After everything, Caesars reported a net loss of $123 million.
That is the public company's problem. The casinos earn real money, but after lenders and landlords are paid, little is left to show shareholders. A private owner only needs the cash to cover the debt and the rent, year after year, with no quarterly loss to explain. Golden's chairman said as much: being private lets the company focus on running its casinos without the distractions of being publicly traded. Same casino, same customers, same cash. Only the buyer changed.
This is easier because the industry split in two. Since Penn National Gaming spun off its real estate as Gaming and Leisure Properties in 2013, and Caesars did the same with VICI Properties in 2017, landlords have owned many casinos and operators have rented them. VICI now owns Caesars Palace, MGM Grand and the Venetian.
That makes each deal smaller. Golden shows how. VICI paid $1.16 billion for the land and buildings of seven Golden casinos. A company controlled by Golden's chairman, Blake Sartini, bought the operating business and now pays VICI rent. The landlord bought the walls. The founder kept the business.
In every case, the people closest to the casinos believed they were worth more than the market was paying, steady cash made the numbers work, and the line between owning the building and running the business shaped the deal. Caesars still needs regulators: the Federal Trade Commission has asked both companies for more information. Churchill Downs owns the real estate under all nine casinos it is selling, which Truist Securities says appeals to buyers, with interest expected from tribal operators and private equity.
On 1 June, People Inc., already MGM's largest shareholder with about 27 percent, offered to take MGM private in a deal valued at about $18 billion. On 23 September it withdrew, saying the pieces hadn't come together. MGM's shares fell about 8 percent. In October, People agreed to cap its stake at 29.9 percent and vote with MGM's board on any future sale. Belief in the value wasn't enough. Price, financing and timing still decide.
For regional casinos, this matters most. Caesars' regional revenue grew almost 6 percent in the third quarter while Las Vegas fell. Steady local cash is what private owners want. Expect more regional casinos to change hands, one at a time.
For the next buyers, the door is open but not cheap. The winners will know how a casino makes its money, and will work with a landlord rather than around one. For anyone outside gaming, this is a rare moment. But a casino is a licensed business, and every new owner has to pass the regulator, not just the bank.
Casinos leaving the stock market is not a sign the business is weak. It is a sign the business is strong in a way the market no longer rewards. Our November report, Off the Board, is free on our site, with no paywall. Download it, and tell me whether you are buying, selling, or still watching.
By Stephen A. Crystal, Founder & CEO, SCCG Management. The Gambling Industry's Global Connector.
Gaming, betting and prediction markets — the desk’s read, every weekday.
Subscribe →